The test of the Tesla Roadster electric sports car on BBC's Top Gear has caused sparks to fly on tech news sites. Jeremy Clarkson reported that the Roadster ran out of charge after a scant 55 miles of hammering around the test track at Dunsfold Park airfield in Surrey. He also charged that the silver Roadster was unreliable, suffering "engine" overheating and "brake failure" which required it to be pushed back to the garage -- charges denied by Tesla's Rachel Konrad in a blog post.

On the other hand, John Carmack seems to be very happy with his new purchase. I love this part:-

"I do also confess to enjoying the irony of my driving an electric car. I am fairly hostile to most of the environmental movement, finding it generally a modern tribal religion that justifies condemnation and control of others in the name of protecting the environment. I care nothing at all for the environment in isolation, only for how it positively impacts human life -- civilization is all about beating the environment into forms that suit us better. An "electric car" used to be a conspicuous sign of righteous sacrifice, but you won't get any self-flagellation points for driving a Tesla. Too much fun. "

Personally, I want to see an Electric Lightning and a Tesla Roadster on the track together.

If we can build electric supercars, why can't we build rockets too? If Musk can do it, why can't we? ;-)

UPDATE: BBC admits it made stuff up (surprise!). The Tesla didn't run out of charge, and was only filmed being pushed back to the garage to show what would happen if the Roadster had run out of charge. So that's all right then :-p "Top Gear stands by the findings in this film and is content that it offers a fair representation of the Tesla's performance on the day it was tested," the BBC said in statement

• Tesla - Lots more to come -- BBC Top Gear